MentalPolyphonics
You ain't gotta be in jail to be doin' time.
I’m taking a course called “Deliberation, Civic Engagement and Public Policy”. The two main textbooks are specifically about “deliberative democracy”.
Deliberative democracy is contrasted with liberal democracy: elected representatives passing laws constrained by a (judicially-interpreted) constitution. Citizens are responsible for voting and monitoring their representatives. Liberal democracy is criticized using the public choice model: representatives are lobbied by various special interest groups, and the interests with the most influence get the policy they want.
But having read the introductions to the textbooks I’m not clear what deliberative democracy is like:
If it’s negotiation, then we must assume that citizens have coherent positions but they don’t necessarily need to explain them. If it’s debate, then arguments are what matters and deliberators can arrive at a solution based on the process without having coherent positions.
What are the qualities of good deliberators? Is flashy rhetoric a threat? Do they need to be open to other people’s points of view, or just open to negotiating a compromise?
And when we talk about representatives “deliberating” in parliament today, which activity are they doing? Or are they just posturing for the press?
MentalPolyphonics » Homework: Powering Up Deliberative Democracy
on May 21, 2010 at 7:29 am
[...] come to learn that there are a lot of things that people call “deliberative democracy“. So this paper focuses on a particular kind of deliberative democracy: “empowered [...]
MentalPolyphonics » The World Turns Oral
on June 7, 2010 at 7:20 am
[...] I get the sense, from YouTube to Obama to TED Talks to deliberative democracy to the slam poetry reading I went to last week, that our society is taking an oral turn. I’m [...]
MentalPolyphonics » Homework: Deliberating with Aliens
on June 10, 2010 at 12:05 pm
[...] theorists on deliberative democracy distinguish it from negotiation in that participants need to give reasons for their positions. The reasons don’t need to be [...]
MentalPolyphonics » Victoria Community Planning Forum: Neighbourhoods
on July 1, 2010 at 9:13 am
[...] sessions really disappointed my hopes for deliberation. It was more a process [...]